An Overdrive survey from a year ago showed minimal e-logging by owner-operators. Since then, many larger fleets have added ELD systems to get a jump on compliance before Dec. 18, but most independent owner-operators have yet to install an ELD.
Since the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s late 2015 release of its final rule for using electronic logging devices, there’s been a rising swell of ELD development. Customers can choose from hardware and software options offered by dozens of vendors, many of them new to the trucking industry.
This also means serious preparation on the enforcement side. FMCSA has had reported delays implementing its roadside data-transfer system by which officers will interface electronically with any of these systems. Nevertheless, the agency expects to have it in place prior to Dec. 18, the scheduled enforcement date for using electronic logs.
Fleet-focused onboard devices offer a lot of bells and whistles, but independent owner-operators are likely to gravitate to a baseline-compliance device. They can benefit from additional functions such as IFTA data collection, making mileage tracking automatic and easily reportable.
As you’re making your decision, consider these issues:
The final rule specifies an eight-day timeframe for repairing/replacing a malfunctioning ELD. Does the provider stock the kind of hardware inventory to meet such a quick turnaround? How are replacements/repairs handled?
For carriers needing more than eight days to replace any ELD, the rule also spelled out a process for requesting more time. It involves contacting your state’s FMCSA division office and making your case.
FMCSA registry and compliance.
Technically, compliant ELDs must be on FMCSA’s registry of devices. The agency’s vetting process does not entail testing for compliance, relying largely on manufacturers to self-certify that they meet the rule specs.
That’s prompted worry among motor carriers about what happens if their device is later found to be noncompliant. FMCSA’s website addresses that scenario: “FMCSA will work with affected motor carriers to establish a reasonable timeframe for replacing non-compliant devices.”
At this stage, part of the complexity involving the registry is that automatic onboard recording devices meeting fairly minimal requirements compared to ELD specs are essentially grandfathered through Dec. 16, 2019. The rule notes that any carrier installing an AOBRD prior to this year’s ELD enforcement date can use that device until the 2019 date.
Practically, what that means is that enforcing the requirement to use a registry-listed device is unlikely before that time, particularly for carriers who comply with the ELD rule and install an engine-connected e-log prior to Dec. 18. So the registry’s importance for carriers choosing ELDs at this stage is minimal.
As the comparison chart of devices shows, many established ELD vendors remain off the registry. Those providers consulted for stories in this buyer’s guide, if not already on the registry, expressed plans for eventual ELD compliance for their products through firmware/software updates as the enforcement rollout progresses.
Nonetheless, for any product not listed on the registry, ask the vendor about its plans for registering its device and whether it has a plan for success and support for its product beyond 2019.
All compliant electronic logging devices will share a common bond: They can record data coming in from the system that controls the truck’s engine and component parts. The ELD final rule from the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration was specific in requiring synchronization with the electronic control module. That’s one of the reasons the agency didn’t require ELDs in trucks of model-year 1999 or older.
The rule requires ELDs to automatically record date, time, location information, engine hours, vehicle miles and identification information for the driver, carrier and vehicle itself. Unless the driver is enabled for use of the vehicle in a “personal conveyance” mode outside of work hours, ELDs are required to record all of those elements “when the driver indicates a change of duty status or a change to a special driving category” such as a yard move, the rule states.
When in motion, ELDs are required to record all of the information on an hourly basis at a minimum. Many ELDs are offered as part of systems built for detailed tracking purposes, useful to fleets and owner-operators for purposes such as automatic notification of arrival times.
Those systems are capable of recording in a much more refined manner, and some may default to that. Providers may or may not have the ability to adjust the refinement.
Though there are plenty of variations, two types of ELDs have emerged.
In dedicated unit configurations, the device is supplied by the provider and is likely to remain in the truck.
BYOD (“bring your own device”) systems allow buyers to purchase their own hardware for the driver interface, such as an owner-operator using an app on a personal Android- or iOS-powered smartphone. A carrier may seek out a deal on tablets to dedicate to its power units and drivers.
Most older forms of electronic logging devices, known as electronic onboard recorders (EOBRs) or automatic onboard recording devices (AOBRDs), have been the dedicated-unit type. Two examples that have been available for years are Omnitracs’ MCP series and PeopleNet’s current products used by many drivers employed by or leased to larger carriers.
Many of these units provide ELD functionality in a single device package tied directly to the ECM by a cable and plug.
Like mobile phones, such units use connections to the cellular network and GPS functionality to deliver on the ELD rule’s requirements for recording location, mileage and engine hours. Data storage occurs using a combination of the internet cloud, back-office servers and the device itself.
A notable exception among devices available for years now exists in the base model of the Continental VDO RoadLog, which is limited to hours of service recording and inspection-report functionality. With no connection to the cellular network with the device, fleets and owner-operators manage data storage via a USB-connected drive to transfer records to a laptop or other computer.
Other dedicated devices may pair two pieces of hardware, bridging the gap between the traditional single-unit EOBR and the two-piece BYOD systems readily available today. In most cases, those devices are in evidence on the quick-comparison chart when a BYOD and a dedicated version exist from one manufacturer. While the J.J. Keller Encompass and Rand McNally DC200 systems both are BYOD-capable, they also are offered with company-branded Android tablets that come preloaded with software: the Compliance Tablet from Keller and the TND from Rand McNally.
Any fleet or owner-operator willing to make the investment in dedicated tablets can turn a BYOD system into a dedicated one. For years, Bill Frerichs of St. Louis-based Frerichs Freight Lines has run the BigRoad logging app on Android tablets dedicated to his 10 trucks. Though Frerichs at press time still was evaluating his options for mandate compliance, moving all 10 of his trucks’ tablets to ELD functionality could be as simple as signing on with BigRoad’s program for leasing engine-connection hardware to pair to the tablets.
Jack Schwalbach, who manages the private fleet of Reinders, a Wisconsin-based turf and irrigation products company, did just that with Geotab. “We have dedicated tablets,” Schwalbach says. “The tablets are used just for logging – the data plan, we have locked down. Everybody’s got their smartphone on their own, so they use that” for anything else.
Bring your own device
The “bring your own device” phrase and its BYOD acronym came into use with the profusion of smartphones over the past decade. In trucking, it’s a common term to describe a major part of today’s ELD market.
Dozens of providers are offering their own versions of BYOD systems. A BYOD-configured ELD consists of a “dongle” that connects to the ECM via the cab’s onboard diagnostics port. The dongle typically pairs via a Bluetooth connection with a smartphone or tablet to transmit data.
Software from the ELD vendor on your smartphone or tablet enables you to change duty status manually when you stop. When your vehicle goes into motion, the ELD automatically will shift to the drive line in the log book.
Variations exist. The engine-connection dongle may or may not have a cellular connection. In the case of the KeepTruckin ELD, the ECM-connected device maintains a GPS connection but no cellular connectivity itself. For that, the system relies on the connected smartphone or tablet and its data plan.
Meanwhile, Geotab’s Go — also a BYOD solution (and marketed as the Transflo ELD T7 by Pegasus TransTech) — maintains its own cellular connection and is capable of being updated and troubleshot over the air if software/firmware updates are needed.
While electronic logs generally automate parts of logkeeping and in some ways simplify the rest, they still require direct driver involvement in most duty status changes. As any driver will know, too, turning the entire process over to a device and its interaction with the truck just isn’t possible.
As with paper logs, drivers using electronic logs are in control of all duty status inputs. The exception is the drive line, which functions automatically as specified by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s final rule. It’s also the only status the driver will be unable to edit directly through his driver login.
To minimize the need for annotations required with any edit, the long-in-practice habit of “catching up the logbook” by drivers will mostly fall by the wayside. With no pencil to be pushed across paper, as long as the device is operational and open, duty-status changes happen with the simple push of a button in real time.
Edits made by the driver are possible for every line but the drive line, which is locked down since drive time is based on vehicle movement. The drive line can be edited from the administrator’s account to classify an unassigned driving event or drive time as personal conveyance or a yard move.
Any edits made from the administrator account in the back-office login must be certified as accurate by the driver. This occurs through the driver’s user interface of the ELD when the edit is made.
An independent owner-operator may have two separate logins for the system: one as a driver, the other as the administrator. An independent lacking two email addresses may need to get a second one. Some systems require unique addresses to associate with the logins as administrator and driver-user.
When it comes to the look and feel of the user interface that e-log provider companies are required to produce, the ELD final rule leaves plenty of room for variation. It did, however, make these requirements of all ELDs:
1) A graph grid of any driver user’s hours analogous to that used in paper logs, showing the various off-duty, sleeper berth, driving and on-duty not-driving lines. The grid display – or as an alternative, a printout, being used by Continental’s VDO RoadLog device and its built-in printer – is intended for quick interpretation by law enforcement. This serves as a backup to other required methods of data transfer.
Most providers integrate the grid into the driver’s basic log view on the interface. Many reproduce it with further information in a special inspection screen for display to law enforcement, similar to what officers are used to seeing on paper today.
2) On-duty driving status is required to be triggered automatically when the speed hits 5 mph. If the driver is not logged into the system prior to that change in status, an “unassigned driving event” is recorded by the system and can be reconciled only from the administrator account, not via the driver interface.
According to the rule, after a driving status is triggered, the vehicle is considered in motion by the ELD until “speed falls to 0 miles per hour and stays at 0 miles per hour for 3 consecutive seconds,” after which manual duty status changes are possible.
FMCSA noted it would expect that in most cases drivers would make a duty status change in such an event before shutting the vehicle down. The ELD will record all engine on/off activity.
3) The default duty status for any ELD is on-duty not-driving. Absent a driver’s direct change, after the vehicle has been in motion, the ELD automatically should transfer the driver to Line 4 after the vehicle has been stationary for five minutes.
4) Yard moves functionality was specified in the ELD final rule as a way for carriers to move vehicles around company terminals without automatically triggering an on-duty driving status.
Yard-moves mode for particular drivers will be enabled from the administrator account and then selected by the driver when making a yard move. The default status for a yard move is Line 4, on-duty not-driving.
5) Personal conveyance uses of the truck while off-duty also are enabled from the administrator account for drivers. The personal conveyance mode then can be selected by the driver using the truck for personal reasons during off-duty periods.
Once selected, the default duty status is off-duty for the ELD for as long as it’s selected, including when in motion. GPS refinement is reduced during personal conveyance mode selection from a 1-mile radius to 10 miles.
6) Various hours exemptions and special rule variants such as those pertaining to the 30-minute break and rules for oilfield operations can be handled as they have been, FMCSA’s rule states, via notes sections to the logs.
With the exception of yard moves and personal conveyance, “all other special driving categories, such as adverse driving conditions … or oilfield operations … would be annotated by the driver, similar to the way they are now.”
However, numerous ELD providers support special oilfield rule sets, including Apollo, E-Log Plus, Hutch, Omnitracs’ XRS device, PeopleNet and others.
As efforts to derail the electronic logging device mandate continue to fail, more fleet owners are considering their options. With the mandate’s Dec. 18 enforcement date only a month away, software and hardware providers old and new are trying to set themselves apart.
For the fleet owner who’s certain to be part of the industry for a long time and who wants simplicity at a low price, the devices available without a monthly subscription fee can be a good match.
As of press time, five providers offered either a dedicated-unit or BYOD (bring your own device) ELD for a onetime purchase price. For the four BYOD devices here, freeware installed on a phone or tablet supports the engine plug-in for full in-cab and/or back-office functionality. For the one dedicated unit provider, Continental’s VDO RoadLog is supported via laptop software and a USB-based data transfer device for updates.
Prices overall have continued to fall. What might be the most affordable device, One20’s provocatively named F-ELD, is available for $170 and even less for drivers eligible for discounts.
If results of a 2016 Comdata survey are any indication, the F-ELD and other generally low-cost ELDs are about to see a surge in orders. Cost was identified as the top selection criteria of a third of all respondents.
Cost was a factor for Utah-based Wade Spencer, owner of a four-truck fleet of Freightliner Cascadias outfitted with Blue Ink Technology’s BIT ELD. The BIT electronic control module plug-in device is available for $295, ordered directly through the company’s website. Free smartphone/tablet apps available for both Android and iOS devices provide the driver interface.
For his reefer fleet, Spencer invested in four BITs for his own 2015 Cascadia, the truck of his Utah-based partner-owner and two operated by drivers in Ohio. To serve the company’s principal shipper account, Spencer and the partner load out of Utah and meet the company’s other two Ohio-based drivers in Morris, Illinois, to swap loaded reefers with the others’ empties.
Adding ELDs was just another expense to be minimized. Spencer says his biggest issue with another BYOD ELD product he tried, BigRoad, was its monthly fee. BigRoad charges $25 per truck for full ELD service.
With BIT, he’s eliminated those fees and also mitigated an issue he saw with BigRoad and BYOD ELD competitor KeepTruckin. “They don’t leave things simple” when it comes to the driver’s navigation upon making changes, in Spencer’s view. “My partner’s 72 years old, almost done [trucking]. I’m 47. One of our [Ohio] drivers is 58 or 59, one is 68. I’ve got older drivers who can’t stand change and technology.”
With brothers Mike and Chris Riegel of Blue Ink, Spencer believes he’s found a company committed to simplicity.“I said, ‘If you’re going to make changes, leave the old version, or have the option to leave the screens as they sit. I cannot deal with lots of changes with these guys who just don’t want to deal with technology.’ ” Spencer proposed a fix, and they accommodated that and other suggestions, he says.
All five companies to one degree or another sing the same tune, offering low costs and simplicity to appeal to the small fleet market.
Zed, whose Zed Connect ELD is its first product, was launched by Cummins as a separate but affiliated company to provide technology features to fleets. “There are a lot of truckers out there who don’t want to have that monthly fee and the charges for a lot of things that aren’t applicable to their business,” said Jill Nowlin, sales director.
One20’s marketing of the F-ELD, as suggested by the name, is targeted directly to those who see the mandated shift to e-logs as little more than a nuisance or worse. The driver-oriented company’s principal smartphone app attempts to harness the buying power of groups to deliver discounts on services and products on the road.
Continental has long spoken of its noncellular base model VDO RoadLog as a small fleet-focused device. Sales manager Jeff Waterstreet notes ongoing confidence in that pitch, though the RoadLog is the most expensive among devices without monthly fees.
“VDO is maybe the only appliance-type device that’s out there specifically designed to record hours of service, Waterstreet says.
Also given that it doesn’t open up a cellular connection to the internet, Waterstreet believes it will appeal to a small fleet interested in covering the need for an ELD with a device dedicated to logging and little else.
The company’s positioned to service its user base in the event of malfunctions, given a distribution network that includes most major truck dealers. Hotshot driver Buster Lewis, based near Charlotte, North Carolina, runs with the VDO RoadLog and lauds Continental’s technical support. “This company has treated me like I have a fleet of trucks,” Lewis says.
The RoadLog comes with a built-in printer and a one-year warranty, which the company honored twice for Lewis after early iterations of the product gave him trouble.
Yet another trucking household name has gotten into this market, turning heads earlier in the year when it announced intentions to market a no-monthly-fee ELD product. Garmin’s eLog ECM plug-in ($250) is operable with BYOD Android and iOS devices and also is compatible with the company’s dezl line of truck-specific GPS navigators.
Says Tim Farrell, Garmin’s national accounts sales manager, “We saw a need for one that was not going to require a subscription and major installation processes with third parties being involved.”
The Garmin eLog plugs into the diagnostics port and has a built-in nine-pin connector.
“We also include a six-pin adapter,” enabling it to cover the majority of commercial trucks, Farrell says, though Mack/Volvo is a bit different. “No subscription is a huge benefit,” he says.
Farrell also sees his company’s pricing model as covering a hole in the ELD market, one that’s going to give all of them a leg up in the mad dash to adopt as Dec. 18 approaches.
“We’ve definitely tried to make sure we’ve got things set up with our distributor partners and key retailers that will be carrying it,” Farrell says. “It’s a sort of onetime thing. It’s a push all at once, and it may be a consistent sales volume after that.”
In a perfect world, any ELD software developer could leverage the mileage and engine data from telematics devices that truck makers install at the factory. The data could be accessed by a mobile app through a local Bluetooth connection or be fed to apps installed on a truck’s touchscreen infotainment system.
Absent a printer as a backup, the ELD rule requires that logs be viewable by law enforcement officers in a display. For this reason, it might not make sense for truck makers to install a computing device with a non-mobile display, says Wes Mays, director of OEM solutions for Omnitracs.
Most truck makers are not in the ELD business — at least not yet — but their investments in remote diagnostics and telematics can pay dividends for third-party ELD providers.
Paccar installs a PeopleNet telematics unit in Kenworth and Peterbilt trucks with Paccar MX-13 engines at the factory. To run PeopleNet’s eDriver Logs application, truck owners would need to purchase or lease one of the vendor’s driver displays, but they would gain additional value beyond compliance.
“The customer gets access to Paccar’s detailed and advanced maintenance services preloaded on the device, along with PeopleNet’s fleet management capabilities,” says Eric Witty, vice president of product for PeopleNet.
Daimler Trucks North America installs Zonar’s telematics unit, the V3, in Freightliner and Western Star trucks at the factory. DTNA uses V3 to power its Virtual Technician remote diagnostics service, allowing Zonar’s Connect and 2020 tablets to run the ELD application.
The 2018 Freightliner Cascadia has a new platform with the capability to integrate with other third-party ELD applications, says Greg Treinen, sales and marketing manager of connectivity for DTNA.
Navistar recently expanded its OnCommand Connection diagnostics platform. The company rolled out OnCommand Connection Telematics and OnCommand Connection Marketplace, which features an ELD app. See the chart below for more information.
Several providers did not meet the deadline to be included in the chart below with this package of stories, and can be examined online at OverdriveOnline.com/2015ELDChart.
As new products are introduced and existing products are added to the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s ELD registry, that online chart will be updated.
> > > > > Scroll the chart right to examine the full range of devices. > > > > >
|Provider||A1 ELD||Apollo Solutions||AT&T Fleet Complete||ATS Fleet Management Solutions||BigRoad||Blue Ink Technology||Blue Tree Systems||CarrierWeb||Cartasite||Continental||Coretex||Dispatching Solutions||DriveELD||DriverTech||Eclipse Software||E-Log Plus||ELD Solutions||EROAD||Fleetmatics||FleetUp||Forward Thinking Systems||Garmin International||GeoSpace Labs||Geotab||Gorilla Safety||Gorilla Safety||GPS Insight||HOS 247||HOS Reporter||Hutch||iGlobal||ISE Fleet Services||J.J. Keller||KeepTruckin||Konexial||Linxup||Load Logistics||M2M in Motion||Magellan||Maven Machines||MiX Telematics||Mobile Warrior||Navistar||Nero Global Tracking||Omnitracs||Omnitracs||One20||Pedigree Technologies||Pegasus TransTech||PeopleNet||Quartix||Rand McNally||Rand McNally||Rand McNally||Simple Truck ELD||Spireon||Stoneridge||Switchboard||Teletrac Navman||Telogis||Trimble||TruckX||TruxTrax||Utech||Zed Connect||Zonar|
|Device Name||A1 ELD||Apollo||AT&T Fleet Complete ELD||ELD ABW w/ ATS e-Track Certified||DashLink ELD||BIT ELD||BT500||CarrierMate||DriveTime||VDO RoadLog||Coretex DRIVE||DSI eLogs||DriveELD||DT4000 Rev 7||RapidLog ELD-200||E-Log Plus||ELDS||EROAD ELD||REVEAL LogBook ELD||FleetUp||Field Warrior||Garmin eLog||HG100||Geotab GO||Prime8 ELD||Flex AOBRD||ELD-2000||HOS 247 ELD & ELD Connect||Atlas||Mercury||Edge MDT / Journey8 tablet||eFleetSuite||Encompass||KeepTruckin||My20||Linxup ELD||Load Logistics TMS||M2M018||Magellan HOS Compliance||Maven ELD||MiX Rovi||iDDL||OnCommand Connection||Nero Global Tracking||MCP/IVG||XRS||F-ELD||ELD Chrome||Transflo ELD T7||eDriver Logs||Electronic Logging from Quartix||DC200||TND765||ELD50||Simple Truck ELD||FleetLocate Compliance||EZ-ELD||Switchboard Mobile||Director Drive||Telogis WorkPlan||FieldMaster Logs||XELD||TruxBox ELD||GPSTab ELD Edition||Zed ELD||Zonar Logs|
|Type of Device||BYOD | Android | or dedicated unit||BYOD | Android, iOS||BYOD | Android, iOS | tablet option available||BYOD | Android||BYOD | Android, iOS||BYOD | Android, iOS||BYOD | Android||Dedicated unit | two options, Win-CE (5700) and Android (7000) OS||BYOD | Android, iOS | or paired with ruggedized tablet||Dedicated unit||Dedicated unit||Dedicated unit or BYOD | Android, iOS||BYOD | Android, iOS apps coming soon||Dedicated unit||BYOD | Android mobile device or Windows laptop||BYOD | Android (iOS coming soon) | or paired with ELP-branded Samsung tablet||BYOD | Android or paired with dedicated tablet||Dedicated unit||BYOD | Android||BYOD | Android, iOS||BYOD | Android (iOS coming soon) w/ Field Warrior app | or paired with dedicated Garmin Fleet series||BYOD | Android, iOS (also compatible with dēzl GPS navigators)||BYOD | Android, iOS||BYOD | Android, iOS||BYOD | Android, iOS | hard mount options available||BYOD | Android, iOS | hard mount options available||Dedicated unit||BYOD | Android (iOS coming soon) or “ELD Connect” dedicated unit||BYOD | Android, iOS||Dedicated unit||Dedicated units||Dedicated unit||BYOD | Android, iOS | or paired with dedicated J.J. Keller Compliance Tablet||BYOD | Android, iOS||BYOD | Android, iOS||Dedicated tablets | Android, iOS options||BYOD | Android tablets||BYOD | Android (iOS coming soon)||Dedicated unit | BYOD select Samsung devices||BYOD | Android, iOS||Dedicated unit||BYOD | Android, iOS||BYOD | Android, iOS||BYOD | Android | or paired with dedicated Android tablet||Dedicated units||BYOD | Company- certified Android devices||BYOD | Android, iOS||Cab-Mate Open: BYOD, Android | Cab-Mate Connect: Dedicated unit | Cab-Mate One: All-in-one plug-and-play||BYOD | Android, iOS||Dedicated units||BYOD | Android tablets||BYOD | Android | or paired with TND tablet||Dedicated unit||BYOD | Android | or paired with TND tablet||BYOD | Android, iOS | tablet options available||BYOD | Android, iOS||BYOD | Android, iOS||BYOD | Android (iOS coming soon)||Dedicated unit||BYOD | Android, iOS||Dedicated unit||BYOD | Android, iOS||BYOD | Android, iOS||BYOD | Android||BYOD | Android, iOS||Dedicated unit | Zonar Android tablet|
|Initial cost||$69 BYOD, $195 dedicated||$0 with lease, $75 to purchase ECM-link||$0||$99 (includes first month of service) or $199 (includes first year)||$0 with lease||$295||$0 with lease/purchase over 3-5 years||$749, lease options available||$0 with lease, $600 approximately with dedicated tablet||$700 or $0 lease option||$200 and higher||$0 for rental option, $199 for BYOD, $495 for dedicated tablet||$0||Starting at $699||$299||$169 in BYOD configuration, higher with tablet||$0 with 3-year hardware lease||$0 with monthly plan||$0||$0 with lease||$0 with hardware lease||$250||$0 with one-year service commitment, otherwise $129||$170||$175 to purchase, $7 monthly to lease||0$||$650 for ELD-2000 and GPS tracking device combination; rental: $150 set-up fee||BYOD: $0 with one-year service commitment, otherwise $69 | Dedicated: $149-$218||$0 w/ 1- or 2-year plan, $50 refundable deposit w/ monthly plans||$475, lease options available||$499 and up, depending on configuration||$575, lease options available||$0 with BYOD option||$0 with hardware lease||$0||$100 with contract, $250 without||$499 for adaptable engine relay||$0 with lease-purchase||$849 for dedicated Magellan bundle | BYOD varies||$180||$0 with lease||$0 with lease, $175||$120||$0 with hardware lease, $200 or higher without||$799 and up depending on model, lease options available||$0 with hardware lease option||$170||$0 with lease, $399-$799 for dedicated unit, $299-$399 for BYOD solution||$99 for hardware/harness, $0 with long-term contract||$0 with lease option up to $2,000, depending on capabilities||$79-$119, depending on available promotions||$399, custom options available for larger fleets||$699, custom options available for larger fleets||$149||$0 for BYOD, $10 for tablet with 200 MB subsequent data allowance||$0 with lease||$149||$250||$0 with lease||$0 with lease option up to $100 and more||$0 with monthly plan||$0||$0||$0 with lease, $200 to purchase ELD plug||$200||Varies according to fleet size and options chosen|
|Ongoing lease or service fees per truck||Monthly: $17-$43, depending on options||Monthly: $15-$40, depending on options||Monthly: $25 and higher||Monthly: $15||Monthly: $15 per user, $10 per truck; $15.60 per user/truck for first 15 months for for 1-2-truck O-Os||$0||Monthly: $20-$55, depending on options||Monthly: $31 and lower||Monthly: $15-$30||$0 for logs, DVIR, IFTA miles||Monthly: $40 and higher||Monthly: $24 with rental, otherwise $18-$28||Annually: $99||Monthly: $30 and higher, depending on options||Monthly: $15-$35, depending on option package||Monthly: $19||Monthly: $20 and higher in BYOD, $50 and higher dedicated||Monthly: $35-$60 depending on options||Monthly: $46||Monthly: $25 and higher||Monthly: $10-$40 depending on device type||$0||Monthly: $17||Monthly: $20-$35 approx.||Monthly: $12-$24||Monthly: $10||Monthly: $35 and higher with ELD and GPS device purchase; Rental monthly: $60 also includes service and installation||BYOD — Monthly: $17-$23, depending on options | Dedicated — $31-$37||Monthly: $10-$18||Monthly: $15 and higher, depending on options||Monthly: $25 and higher, depending options and configuration||Monthly: $24||Monthly: $11 (or less with multi-driver discounting)||Monthly: $20 for service||Monthly: $20, or $10 with three-year commitment||Monthly: $30-$50, depending on options||Monthly: $25 and higher||Monthly: $18 and higher||$0 while under contract for Magellan device | BYOD varies monthly with service bundle||Monthly: $30||Monthly: Varies with service plan/bundle||Monthly: $15-$30||Monthly: $20 and higher||Monthly: $20 and higher||Monthly: $23 and higher||Monthly: $23 and higher||$0||Monthly: $20 and higher||Monthly: $18 and higher, depending on plan selected||Monthly: $30-$60 for service, more with lease if applicable||Monthly: $19.20-$22.20/month (or $4/month on top of InfoPlus tracking system subscription)||Monthly: $25 and higher||Monthly: $20 and higher||Monthly: $15 and higher||Monthly: $19 and higher||Monthly: $28 and higher||Monthly: $15 | Annually: $150||$0||Monthly: $45 and higher depending on options||Monthly: $36 including hardware lease and up||Monthly: $60 and higher, depending on options||Monthly: $15-$21 per-truck, unlimited drivers||Monthly: $20 with one-year commitment, $25 month to month||Monthly: $20||$0||Varies with service plan/features|
|Other capabilities beyond logs||IFTA, truck routing, navigation, dispatch||IFTA, AOBRD/ELD operating modes, signature capture, proactive notifications, back office integration, Canada/California/oilfield support||Customizable for fleet management functions such as dispatching, engine diagnostics, geofencing, driver behavior reporting/management and optional custom integration from Fleet Complete Store||IFTA, optional close support software. ELD ABW otherwise is a baseline compliance device. ATS provides e-Track Certified software that powers it.||Document capture, sharing, back-office dispatch geared to small fleets||IFTA, fault code reading, maintenance features available||Wi-Fi hotspot, driver scoring (in performance, safety, and compliance), navigation, jobs workflow management, reefer temperature monitoring||Driver/truck performance and engine diagnostics/preventive maintenance reporting, in-cab scanning, navigation; road segment speeding available at additional cost||IFTA; work order dispatching; option to pair with driver safety features, scorecards, GPS tracking, notifications, and additional fleet management tools||Built-in thermal printer, real-time data transfer, fuel consumption, engine diagnostics, driver scorecard, integrated dispatch for small fleets||IFTA, driver behavior monitoring, EMS data, vehicle service manager, reefer control, tracking, replay||GPS tracking, transport & order management, smart forms, alerts, geofencing, IFTA, device events, more||Baseline compliance device with limited added features, proactive compliance warnings||Critical-event video recorder; truck safe navigation; TMS integration, workflow and messaging; engine diagnostics; IFTA reporting; custom reporting on 200+ vehicle metrics||Special pricing for current log-audit customers, IFTA, route tracking, phone lock, three-tiered compliance warnings||IFTA, maintenance alerts, oilfield capable, auto-backup to cloud storage account, supports up to 6-driver slip seat||IFTA, driver communication, geofencing, engine diagnostics, custom alerts, 100+ reports, third-party software integrations||Electronic weight-mile tax, IFTA, IRP record-keeping; driver behavior reporting/management; maintenance, fuel and other management functions; geofencing and retrospective event tools; TMS integrations||Work Optimization, over-the-air updates, IFTA data collection, engine diagnostics, route optimization||Patented fuel waste analysis, e-maintenance, engine diagnostics, IFTA, geofencing, voice-over HOS, driving and vehicle alerts, complete trip history, full fleet management solution||Geofencing, maintenance tracking, driver scorecards, IFTA, systems integration, truck-specific navigation, live-streaming cameras, signature/image capture, custom digital forms, mobile timecard verification, custom reporting and alerts, roadside assistance program||IFTA, local transfer of logs via USB/Bluetooth during inspections, in-device storage, quick-glance compliance||Maintenance resolution/tracking, paperless manifests and barcoding, dispatch, time-card functionality, route logging, signature capture, detention tracking/billing, mapping||IFTA data collection, engine diagnostics, driver scorecards and coaching, safety/risk management functions, data integration for management, IOX-expansion, more custom add-ons from Geotab Marketplace||Fleet management portal, user/vehicle list details, driver alerts, integrated AOBRD option, short haul and e-log settings available for blended fleets; “Fleet Xpress” package adds IFTA, fuel consumption reporting, document management, custom policies/procedures, admin/manager alerts; “Extreme” adds patented eDVIR maintenance module, accident reporting, mechanic mobile app, mobile document management system||Available to install only prior to Dec. 18 ELD deadline — AOBRD only. Fleet management portal, user/vehicle list details, driver alerts, short haul and e-log settings available for blended fleets||IFTA data collection, engine diagnostics, routing, hierarchy functions for larger fleets, suite of tailored GPS tracking solutions||IFTA; compliance monitoring; document management; vehicle diagnostics; third party access for shippers, brokers and accountants; custom integrations with dispatch, routing and load boards||Two-in-one AOBRD and ELD; IFTA; 9-Pin, 6-Pin, OBD connector options; support for all state rulesets and exemptions; English, Spanish and French language versions; optional fleet management functions||Wireless and satellite tracking options, IFTA, engine diagnostics, maintenance management, compliance/safety systems, tire pressure/trailer monitoring, signature capture, Canada/U.S. oilfield & utility service vehicle support, scorecards, geofencing, push-to-talk, navigation, more||Edge MDT features ruggedized built-in scanner. Journey8: tablet paired with a wireless dongle to the ECM (optional scanner). 8- and 10-inch screens, a la carte pricing for options, IFTA, driver scorecards/settlements, engine diagnostics, push-to-talk cellular, TMS integrations (TMW, McLeod), more.||IFTA data collection, compliance mapping, customizable||Optional IFTA reporting, navigation, engine diagnostics, driver qualification, drug & alcohol management, accident tracking, training, recordkeeping||IFTA, idle-time tracking, engine diagnostics, geofencing, driver scorecards, TMS integrations (TMW, McLeod)||IFTA, simple install, control tower, dashboards, fuel options, navigation/mapping, patent-pending GoLoad truckload freight-matching||AOBRD/ELD and reporting capabilities, IFTA, tracking/fleet management options||IFTA, dispatch/load functions, engine connection easily transferred from truck to truck, engine diagnostics, lane analysis, customizable for small fleet management||IFTA, engine diagnostics and other management capabilities, dashcam with critical-event capture and deliver, driver scoring, trailer tracking, mobile device management/lockdown capabilities, customizable depending on customer needs||IFTA, refined GPS, other functionality depending on configuration||IFTA; 1-second telematics; hard braking, speeding other automated/customizable alerts; driver safety scoring; patented fatigue/distraction monitoring; California labor law tools||IFTA, geofencing, maintenance tools, driver/vehicle utilization tools, fuel/engine monitoring, journey management, integrated video cameras, distracted and fatigued driving monitoring, collision avoidance, mobile apps for driver gamification/work flow||IFTA, touch-free driver ELD gauge, dispatch/load functions, document capture, time card and expense tracking with integration to accounting, DVIR w/ custom checklists by vehicle, real-time back-end admin portal for office, other custom settings||Vehicle location tracking, geofencing, harsh braking acceleration, idle reporting, breadcrumb trails; error help and alerts of violations; IFTA; advanced vehicle diagnostics||Engine diagnostics, fuel management, IFTA data collection, alerts and reports, geofencing, driver scorecards, maintenance module, more||Engine diagnostics, mobile-based weigh station bypass, IFTA, in-cab scanning, truck navigation, geofencing, custom mobile forms, TMS integration, idle time tracking, video recording, simple installation, more||Base service plan includes engine diagnostics and fuel-purchase and maintenance functions. Premium package includes IFTA and navigation with oilfield capability||Base functionality for logs and DVIR, roadside mode password-protected||IFTA, engine diagnostics standard. Expandable and customizable with fleet management functions, including dispatch, forms, job management, maintenance, tires, seatbelts, trailer tracking, temperature monitoring, TMS integrations, more.||IFTA, maintenance/engine performance data, driver behavior insights, accident detection and reconstruction, TMS integration, loads, dispatch chat, weather,routing, document scanning, settlement statements, more||Customizable for fleet management functions, mobile-based weigh station bypass||In addition to sophisticated tracking tools, fleet management functions (including dashboards), IFTA and more||TMS integration, workflow, IFTA, mapping, analytics, engine diagnostics, cellular modem||Truck-specific navigation, TMS integration, workflow, IFTA, mapping, analytics, diagnostics||TMS integration, workflow, IFTA, mapping, analytics, diagnostics||24/7 support, IFTA, free 2290 filing with affiliated tax service, parking assistance, diagnostic data, load boards and roadside assistance, discounted fuel cards, fuel management options (including in-app camera for receipts), available in Spanish||IFTA, driver safety alerts/reports, driver scores, audible alerts, engine diagnostics||IFTA, engine diagnostics, 3 interchangeable on-board diagnostics (OBD) port connectors, maintenance/driver alerts, sophisticated tracking/vehicle location, 6 months of on-device data storage, more||IFTA, AOBRD option, satellite GPS, geofencing, violation tracking||IFTA, engine diagnostics, dispatch and messaging, safety analytics, workflow solutions, truck-based navigation, driver scorecards, TMS integration, guaranteed compliance with ELD specs||Document capture, trip plan sharing, engine diagnostics and prognostics, more||Rule sets for vocational trucks, driver monitoring, proactive alerts, geofencing, off-road telematics, PTO tracking, engine diagnostics||IFTA, route history, dispatch, share specific load tracking, engine diagnostics, service and maintenance reminders||IFTA, expense and fuel tracking/reporting, more||IFTA, load location sharing with customer, document scanner, driver scorecard, flexible reporting||Route management, fleet dashboard||Wi-Fi and Bluetooth connectivity for dispatch, management, operational functions; camera; navigation; Android compatibility; over-the-air updates|
|On FMCSA ELD registry?||Yes (powered by HOS247)||Yes||Yes (powered by BigRoad)||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||—||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||—||Yes||—||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||—||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||—||Yes||Yes||—||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||—||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||—||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
AT&T Fleet Complete
Fleet Complete provides fleet management telematics and technologies to businesses of all sizes. It has an exclusive relationship with AT&T to provide a nationwide wireless network and an intuitive cloud-based IoT platform. The AT&T Fleet Complete ELD, powered by BigRoad, is designed to be simple and flexible. It automates recordkeeping and improves compliance without interfering with the driver’s actions. The app proactively notifies drivers of hours-of-service violations and form-and-manner errors, allowing them to correct issues before they result in costly fines. It is available on Android and iOS, requiring no proprietary mobile device. There is no initial cost, and the monthly fee starts at $25/month.
The integrated AT&T Fleet Complete BigRoad platform is offered through our North American channel partner, AT&T. We are proud to be the winner of this year’s Frost & Sullivan Award for Customer Value Leadership in ELD Solutions Industry.
AT&T Fleet Complete, ATT.FleetComplete.com/ELD
Compliance Assurance Services TruLog
Compliance Assurance Services’ TruLog is a mobile app for electronic logging device compliance that meets all FMCSA regulatory requirements. The ELD easily plugs in to the vehicle’s electronic control module, which communicates with the app on a mobile device (smartphone or tablet) and transmits required data to update hours-of-service information that is stored securely and shared easily with safety investigators and regulatory agencies. The user-friendly app has a sleek design that’s simple to use and easy to read. The information includes easy-to-understand updates on mileage, fuel and GPS location.
The app’s comprehensive tools provide advanced functionality such as electronic DVIRs, automated maintenance work orders and accident reporting. It is designed for simple, fast image and file uploading, including bills of lading or pictures from an accident. The app’s multi-user capability allows owner-operators to manage two accounts, one as a driver and one as a supervisor.
Compliance Assurance Services, TrulogELD.com
Continental VDO RoadLog
VDO RoadLog has a built-in thermal printer that provides an instant hard copy that resembles a traditional paper logbook grid for an inspection officer to review. A paper printout eliminates technical issues involving transferring log data that otherwise might lead to drivers handing over their personal cell phones to an officer or having the officer climb into the cab to review an electronic logging device screen. VDO RoadLog ELDs work with VDO RoadLog Office, an online fleet management tool for automated compliance reporting designed for fast, secure data transfers and automatic online record backup. The product also helps automate IRP and IFTA reporting, as well as pre-and post-trip inspections.
VDO RoadLog is designed for easy installation and use and is available without monthly fees or contracts. Optional features include Driver/Vehicle Track & Trace, Load & Trip Management, VDO RoadLog Office Advanced and VDO RoadLog Office Premium.
VDO Commercial Vehicles, VDORoadLog.com
The FMCSA-registered Coretex Drive electronic logging device is a purpose-built tablet-based in-cab system that links drivers to vehicles and vehicles to dispatchers. Working in harmony with Coretex 360, Drive gives drivers the information they need to do their jobs efficiently and safely. Built around a modular app framework, Coretex Drive also offers single-pane-of-glass access to turn-by-turn trucking navigation, messaging, jobs, DVIRs, checklists, fatigue information, real-time driver feedback, IFTA data collection, vehicle service management, tracking, replay and a choice of custom applications.
Drive is optimized to run on Coretex-supplied Samsung and TomTom Bridge tablets, and the system also makes it easy to roll out Android-based mobile apps to drivers quickly and securely. The initial cost for the device and service is $750, and the ongoing lease or service fees per truck are $40 per month and higher.
Geotab Drive is a FMCSA-compliant device for monitoring hours of service, DVIRs and driver identification. The app syncs data between the Geotab Go plug-in device and a tablet to provide automatic duty status changes, violation alerts and end-to-end inspection workflow, all in one user-friendly platform. Geotab Drive is compatible with the company’s Go 6 and Go 7 devices, IOX-USB and Android or iOS. In addition to electronic logging, Go’s capabilities include IFTA data collection, engine diagnostics, driver scorecards, safety/risk management functions and data integration for management; more custom additions are available from the Geotab Marketplace.
The initial cost for the FMCSA-registered device is $170, and the ongoing lease or service fee per truck is about $20 to $30 per month.
GPS INSIGHT ELD-2000
GPS Insight’s ELD-2000 system bundles a GPS tracking, alerting and reporting device hardwired to a ruggedized Android tablet designed with an intuitive user interface. The electronic logging device also offers messaging for drivers and dispatch to reduce the number of phone calls and streamline communications with individual drivers or the entire fleet, as well as navigation to allow management to dispatch audible and visual directions using designated truck-specific routes for each job to drivers.
A web-based management portal is accessible via PC, tablet and smartphone. Costs range from $34.96 to $60 depending on customer requirements and purchasing method.
GPS Insight, GPSInsight.com
J.J. Keller Encompass
The J.J. Keller suite of electronic hours-of-service products provides companies a full range of services, including electronic logging device technology, startup assistance, data management and HOS guidance. J.J. Keller ELogs offers flexibility with an ELD that works with all vehicle classes, can be used with drivers’ smart devices and installs in just 10 minutes. J.J. Keller ELogs features the Encompass cloud-based fleet management system that automatically audits drivers’ logs against available HOS rule sets, helping fleet professionals immediately identify violations through exception-based reports and compliance alerts. Encompass offers fleets the ability to accommodate personal conveyance and track nonregulated and exempt drivers, giving companies a real-time view of critical fleet information.
Fleets can upgrade Encompass for automated IFTA reporting; paperless recordkeeping; tracking of driver qualification, alcohol and drug reporting; accident tracking; unit permitting and registration documentation; and more.
J.J. Keller, JJKeller.com/ELogs
Pedigree Technologies Cab-Mate One
Pedigree Technologies recently launched Cab-Mate One as the most affordable and easiest electronic logging plug-and-play device to install (five minutes). The Cab-Mate One is the third addition to the company’s FMCSA-certified ELD Chrome offering, built on the award-winning, intuitive and reliable OneView platform.
Not only are packages based on a customer’s specific needs and budget, the offerings also are developed using customer feedback and real-life applications. This means Android-ready ELD Chrome offers FMCSA compliance with options for expandability into a full suite of comprehensive business management tools, from basic ELD to trailer, equipment and asset tracking and tire pressure, tank level and temperature monitoring. ELD Chrome was designed to enable consistent real-time visibility and actionable information with reliable connectivity and a fleet manager-approved interface.
Monthly fees are as low as $22/month depending on expanded applications and quantity pricing. The Cab-Mate One runs as low at $399 each when purchasing 100 or more units; $0 with lease.
Pedigree Technologies, PedigreeTechnologies.com
Pegasus TransTech Transflo ELD T7
Pegasus TransTech’s Transflo ELD T7 is a BYOD device – smartphone or tablet – that is easy to use and available for both Android and iOS. At less than 3 inches, the device is durable and compact. Plug in and activate in minutes without a mechanic or special tools.
The Standard ELD Plan includes hours-of-service compliance, DVIRs and IFTA reporting information. The premium Fleet Telematics plan adds detailed truck maintenance and engine performance data, as well as driver behavior insights. It’s also available with transportation management software system integration. The hardware is available for less than $99, with monthly subscriptions starting at $18.
Transflo ELD T7 can be integrated with the rest of the Transflo Mobile product suite. Manage not only HOS but also loads, dispatch chat, weather and routing, document scanning, settlement statements and more. The device is available for purchase from Transflo, Transflo channel partners and Pilot Flying J, Love’s and TA Petro travel stops.
Pegasus TransTech, Transflo.com
Electronic Logging from Quartix
Vehicle tracking specialists Quartix’s Electronic Logging product puts its current and future customers into compliance with FMCSA’s mandate. It can be installed on its own or partnered with the company’s comprehensive vehicle tracking services. Available on the Google Play Store and compatible with Android tablet devices, Quartix’s Electronic Logging uses simple menu screens and input fields that allow drivers to log and change their duty status with minimal effort.
“Having been in the vehicle telematics industry for over 15 years providing fleet owners with management reports extending from real-time GPS tracking to IFTA filing figures, we are delighted to be able to further support our growing long-haul trucking customer base with our FMCSA-compliant solution,” says Ed Ralph, Quartix chief operating officer.
Starting at just $14.99, Quartix’s Electronic Logging is affordable for any budget.
UTech GPSTab ELD Edition
GPSTab ELD Edition provides a powerful suite of tools to help you manage your fleet and comply with FMCSA regulations (AOBRD option coming soon). Evaluate the product risk-free with the company’s 30-day money-back guarantee with no contract and an “If Repealed” buy-back program and free software option for 2017.
It features live GPS tracking, location sharing, document scanning, driver scorecards, IFTA accounting, messaging, flexible reporting, detention hours tracking and telematics. The ability to share live shipment locations with customers reduces unnecessary tracking-related correspondence, enabling dispatchers to manage more accounts and focus on customer service. Tracking intervals from five seconds to one hour supply fleet owners with accurate, relevant information for better fleet management. Monitor location, speed, miles traveled, route selection and other driver activities to improve overall fleet safety and operations.
Alerts help drivers prevent violations, and proof of detention time and document scanning help drivers get paid faster.
GPSTab ELD Edition, GPSTab.com
Zonar Connect is a dedicated electronic logging device-compliant tablet that also offers Wi-Fi and Bluetooth connectivity for dispatch, management and operational functions, as well as a camera, navigation, Android compatibility and over-the-air updates. Zonar Connect is connected even when outside of the cab, allowing the driver to submit completed documents and electronic DVIRs to dispatch without returning to the truck. The tablet recharges in its in-cab cradle and integrates with the company’s Ground Traffic Control to help provide fleets with better visibility of assets on the road.
Pricing for the unit and ongoing service varies according to ﬂeet size, service plan and options chosen.