Trucking economic outlook — Risk factors to watch for in 2013

By Avery Vise on

As part of CCJ’s ongoing “On Thin Ice?” series, Part 3 details what risk factors fleets should watch for in 2013.  Part 1 offers commentary from analysts and fleets as to what they see happening in 2013 as far as freight and the economy are concerned — see it herePart 2 delves into the impact changing regulations from the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration could have on trucking — and fleets, specifically — in 2013, as well as surviving in the current economic environment. See it here.

Watching the risk factors

No credible economist claims that his forecast is an ironclad certainty. Analysts speak in terms of upside risks and downside risks – the chances that reality will be better or worse than they have predicted. For FTR’s Perry, most of the risks are on the downside. “If you take away the global exposures, this recovery could last through 2015.” He cites three external events, however, that could change things.

Percentage of trucking executives who say item did or will rise the most in percentage terms over prior year. With the Supreme Court’s decision last June and President Obama’s reelection in November, trucking companies are bracing for a rise in health care costs. More than a quarter say those costs will rise the most in percentage terms during 2013.

First, a war in the Middle East could cost the world 2.5 million barrels of oil a day. “That could be enough of a shock to put us into recession,” Perry says.

Second, the markets already have factored in a European recession but not a collapse in the Euro. “That will occur given the current political trajectory, but I don’t think it will happen in 2013,” Perry says. The result would be an international banking crisis.

Third, the Chinese economy is approaching maturity, and recessions happen when people overbuild, Perry says. Clearly, China is creating a bubble in both housing and infrastructure, and “it’s certain that within the next 10 years, China will have a recession.” A downturn in the Chinese economy is the biggest risk for a U.S. recession, “but that’s more of a 2015 thing than a 2013 thing.”

Changes in truck fleet size?
Percentage of trucking executives reporting a change or expecting it compared to the prior year: Most carriers expect to hold steady on their fleet size in 2013. Few expect to shrink in 2013, but that might be because many already have done so. Nearly 16 percent of carriers – including 22 percent of those with 100 or fewer trucks – said they reduced their fleet size in 2012.

The chance of recession in 2013 barring war in the Middle East is small, Perry says. “I think there’s a good chance for a positive surprise in 2013, but hold on because something bad is going to happen thereafter.”

Larkin adds another downside risk factor on the domestic front: “We don’t know the cost of Obamacare.” Perhaps not, but trucking companies believe that health care costs will rise sharply in 2013. The November 2012 Randall-Reilly survey found that more carriers believe health care-related expenses will be their fastest-rising costs in 2013 than any other cost. “In a period of uncertainty, people aren’t going to make big bets,” Larkin says.

That’s certainly how John Miller sees things. “We have put our planned purchases of tractors on hold due to the uncertainty of the economy as well as Obamacare,” says Miller, executive vice president of Birmingham, Ala.-based Ross Neely Systems.

Want a downloadable PDF of survey results, comments from the research and quick summation for reference or to handout to co-workers? Click the photo above — or click here.

Larkin does see some upside trends. As Western tastes and appetites grow in developing countries, exports also will grow. “And the whole near-shoring/insourcing phenomenon is a big plus,” he says. The advent of robotics makes U.S. manufacturing competitive when taking into account both labor and transportation costs.

Those are developments to watch mostly in the coming years, however. For now, it would seem that 2013 could be better than 2012 but not necessarily great. We should see continued gradual recovery in freight demand coupled with tighter capacity that could make business better for the carriers that can weather the challenges. But it also will be an economy that could break at any moment.

Says Jim Subler, president of Versailles, Ohio-based Classic Carriers, “I feel the next four years will be like the last two – not any type of real recovery, but just skimming along the edge of another downturn.”

Avery Vise

Avery Vise is executive director, trucking research and analysis for Randall-Reilly Business Media and also serves as senior editor, industry analysis for Commercial Carrier Journal. Previously, he was editorial director of Randall-Reilly’s Fleet/Dealer/Aftermarket group and had served as chief editor of CCJ for 10 years. From 1985 to 1998, Vise worked for McGraw-Hill’s Aviation Week Group, covering Congress and the Department of Transportation for publications about the commercial aviation industry. He has received numerous awards from American Business Media and the American Society of Business Publication Editors for his coverage of the trucking industry. Vise is a graduate of Georgetown University in Washington, D.C., with degrees in government and history.

0 comments

Must Clicks