Owner to outlaw: How Motus forced trucker to skirt rules he says he never broke

Man wearing tan cowboy hat and blue mirrored sunglasses smiling at camera outdoors
Owner-operator Darryl Gibbs spent almost three months running a trucking operation with an inactive DOT number, and did everything he could to fix it.

After 20 years in the Air Force Reserve and more than 40 years behind the wheel of a commercial truck, Darryl Gibbs thought he'd jumped every hurdle trucking could throw at him.

But the owner-operator and Aurora, Colorado, resident recently found himself in uncharted waters -- at least uncharted for him. The reality is Gibbs was far from alone. He's one of thousands of trucking companies rendered inactive by administrative headaches that have plagued the government's new registration platform, Motus, since its debut in May.

Gibbs’ company, Dragon Logistics, hauls ag and livestock, but for almost three months his USDOT number showed inactive status within the Motus system, and he had no idea why. Inactivations were very common in the early Motus-transition period. Along with authority suspensions for no clear reason, they've been among the more common issues for surprise deactivations, according to Overdrive/CCJ sister Fusable company Central Analysis Bureau (CAB)

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration did not respond to our request for comment for this story, but 16 hours and 26 minutes after our query to the agency, Dragon Logistics' DOT number was reactivated.

Gibbs and his company were just a week away from having been inactive for three months. Gibbs showed inactive for almost a month before he even knew it.

"The only reason I found out about it is SmartFreight said something to me," he said. "They said, 'Hey, you know that you're inactive?' I was like, 'I'm not inactive.'"

Yes, he was.

Maroon Peterbilt livestock transport semi-truck with silver aluminum trailer parked in rural lotGibbs hauls livestock with this pictured Pete.

According to Gibbs, his third-party filing representative at ProRate 48 had been in direct contact with FMCSA to resolve the issue, and representatives for the agency allegedly admitted that the root of the problem lay entirely on their end, explaining that agency computer systems "stopped talking to each other" and that the USDOT number must be manually linked before the error could be corrected.

Compounding the frustration, federal officials told the filing service that they "cannot give us a timeline of when this will be resolved," according to Gibbs. 

Partner Insights
Information to advance your business from industry suppliers

Despite repeated attempts to escalate the matter through the agency's support channels, Gibbs said responses have been nonexistent, and hours spent on hold yielded no solutions, an experience that's hasn't exactly been uncommon since the Motus transition and ensuing mess began.

[Related: Motus mess improving, little by little? Weigh in]

"We have done everything right and on time on our end," Gibbs said. "I should not be penalized for FMCSA’s mistake."

The glitch, whatever it was, not only put Gibbs' business at risk, "it’s my wife’s and my livelihood, our home and our mortgage, and everything we’ve worked for," he said.

Gibbs reached out to the congressional offices of Rep. Jason Crow and Sen. John Hickenlooper for assistance, though he has yet to receive a response.

Gibbs noted that the inactive status was visible to brokers and shippers, creating complications, and any routine roadside inspection could have placed his truck out of service -- a dangerous scenario when hauling live cargo as he does.

That turmoil put Gibbs, a self-described by-the-book rule follower, in an uncomfortable position: outlaw trucker.

"I can't shut down, because if I shut down, I'm going to lose my house," he said. "We would have already lost the house. We would lose everything. That includes my insurance. As soon as I miss a payment on my insurance, my insurance is done. If my insurance is done, then I lose my authority, then that means I've got to start all over.

Just in case he did get stopped, he carried "my MCS-150 biannual certification with me," he said, "but that's not guaranteeing me anything."

Fortunately, Gibbs never had to cross that bridge with inspectors the months he spent as an outlaw through no fault of his own. With any luck, his DOT's reactivation keeps him in the clear for the remainder of the year and beyond. 

[Related: 5K trucking authorities suspended in single day: Motus still messy]

Jason Cannon has written about trucking and transportation for more than a decade and serves as Chief Editor of Commercial Carrier Journal. A Class A CDL holder, Jason is a graduate of the Porsche Sport Driving School, an honorary Duckmaster at The Peabody in Memphis, Tennessee, and a purple belt in Brazilian jiu jitsu. Reach him at [email protected]. 
Looking for your next job?
Careersingear.com is the go-to platform for the Trucking industry. Don’t just find the job you need; find the job you want with the company that wants you!