FMCSA's pending pile is 43% larger and nearly twice as old as it was in August

The pile grew by 7,806 in 83 days, almost all of it without an insurance filing, and I can find no public dismissal decision for an application opened in Motus.

Data analysis of the FMCSA’s Motus registration system reveals a growing backlog of stalled carrier applications lacking insurance proofs, raising questions about agency enforcement and capacity tracking.

  • Backlog Growth: Total pending applications in the Motus system jumped from 18,000 on August 23 to 25,806 by November 14, with median file ages doubling from 36 days to 70.
  • The Missing Filings: Stalled applications—defined as those lacking a liability insurance filing—account for 94.6% (24,408) of the entire pending pile, though thousands of separate grants continue to be processed.
  • Absence of Dismissals: Despite FMCSA guidelines stating stalled applications should face dismissal around 90 days, public records and the Motus Register show virtually no dismissal decisions being issued or logged since mid-May.
  • Vetting Implications: Compliance experts caution that pending records do not equate to active operating authorities or trucks on the road, requiring motor carriers and brokers to carefully verify active status rather than relying on pending dockets.

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration's Motus Carrier table holds 7,806 more pending applications than when I first counted it Aug. 23, and the median file age has nearly doubled, from 36 days to 70.

CCJ published that first count Aug. 31. I ran it again on the file as refreshed Nov. 14. A stalled application, here as then, is a pending one with no liability insurance filing on record. Each record is one authority on one docket, so a company seeking two counts twice.

Four measures, Aug. 23 and Nov. 14:

  • Pending applications: 18,000; now 25,806.
  • Stalled, with no liability filing on record: 16,606 (92.3%); now 24,408 (94.6%).
  • Median file age: 36 days; now 70.
  • Stalled files older than the roughly 90-day window FMCSA's guidance describes before dismissal: 627; now 9,175.

Part of that last jump is arithmetic: Motus-era applications begin May 18, the day before the system opened to all registrants, so on Aug. 23 only the first week's could have crossed 90 days. On Nov. 14, the oldest of them were 180 days old, and 1,068 stalled applications opened in May were still pending.

Nearly all of the growth has no insurance filing

The pile's net growth since August is 7,806 applications, and the stalled side accounts for 7,802 of it. That does not mean nobody is getting insured.

FMCSA's insurance filing page says no operating authority is granted until the applicant's minimum financial responsibility is in effect and on file with the agency, and grants have kept coming. As of Nov. 15 the agency's authority status history file recorded 10,928 applications opened and 5,001 authorities granted in September, and 8,733 opened and 6,959 granted in October. Granted applications leave the pile; what builds up is the part with no filing.

Brokers and freight forwarders show financial responsibility mainly with a bond or trust rather than a liability filing, so the cleaner measure is motor carriers alone: 22,527 stalled applications on Nov. 14, with a median age of 69 days and 8,413 older than 90 days.

Half were granted, one in nine was withdrawn, four in 10 are still open

To see outcomes, I followed one group through the history file: the 24,343 applications opened in Motus between May 19 and Aug. 16, every one of them more than 90 days old by Nov. 15. By then:

  • 12,120 had been granted. The median grant came 29 days after opening, and 765 grants came after day 90.
  • 2,678 had been withdrawn, each under a user account that in nearly every case appears to be the applicant's own or a filing service's.
  • 9,510 showed nothing after the opening record: no grant, withdrawal, or other outcome.
  • 35 showed some other status.

Applications that are going to be granted mostly leave within a month or two, which is how the pile can be 94.6% stalled while about half of that group got through.

Partner Insights
Information to advance your business from industry suppliers

No public dismissal decision for a Motus-era application

One outcome is missing from that list: the one FMCSA's own pages describe for a stalled application. Under the agency's FAQ on dismissed applications, an application that still has no proof of insurance and no process agent named approximately 90 days from filing is dismissed. Its insurance filing page gives the steps: the applicant gets 20 days from the day the application notice publishes in the FMCSA Register; after that comes a decision, served on the applicant, that gives 60 more days.

For applications opened in Motus, I cannot find that step in public. The agency issues its Register through Motus, and the 128 issues published there from May 19 through Nov. 13 hold application notices and no dismissal decisions. As of Nov. 15, the history file has no record dated after mid-May that carries a dismissal reason. Nearly all the exits it shows since mid-May are grants and withdrawals, and nearly all of the roughly 5,500 withdrawals were entered under user accounts that appear to be the applicants' own or their filing services'.

That does not show that FMCSA has stopped dismissing applications. I do not know whether the agency has stopped issuing these decisions, is deferring them, or is serving them in a way that reaches neither the Register nor the open data; the Motus Register itself says applicants get their filing deadlines by letter. I have found no FMCSA statement on whether dismissal decisions are still being issued. From my own desk, I can add one thing: none of the applicants I work with has shown me a dismissal decision, or a warning of one, since late May.

Pending is not a permit, and it is not a denial

If you use the pending count to gauge capacity: read 25,806 as an inventory of unfinished applications, not as a count of trucks on the way. With grants and withdrawals nearly the only recorded ways out, the pile still holds stalled files from May. Grants track new authority: 5,001 in September, 6,959 in October.

If you vet carriers: a pending record is a different thing from the suspensions CCJ reported Oct. 29. That report, citing CAB, said roughly 6,000 companies were involuntarily suspended that week after the liability limit Motus required of them changed. A pending record, with few exceptions, belongs to an applicant that has not been granted that authority. Look it up on Motus Public Search by USDOT number or by legal or DBA name, and read the current status, the status reason and the insurance details. A docket number is not authorization, and neither is a Register notice, as the Register's own disclaimer says. Then look again before you write the applicant off: 765 grants in the May-to-August group came after day 90.

If you are opening a company or adding an authority: the rule and FMCSA's FAQ read as they did in August. The 20 days still run from publication (49 CFR 365.109T), the FAQ still calls a dismissal the equivalent of a rejection, and the filing fee is not refunded whether an application is granted, dismissed or withdrawn (49 CFR 360.3T). Motus assigns each operating authority its own docket number, so each authority you request is its own pending record and needs its own filings.

Since 2019, I have helped file authority applications every week, and on the public record, I cannot tell an applicant what happens to a file on day 91. I can tell them what is due by day 20 after the notice publishes: the financial responsibility filing and the process agent designation.

Methodology:

Sources, pulled Nov. 15 from data.transportation.gov: FMCSA's Motus registration and authority table (inys-ebih), refreshed Nov. 14, and its Motus authority status history (yu5v-wbh6), refreshed Nov. 15.

Pending is op_auth_status = 'Pending'; no filing is bipd_file zero or empty. Age runs to Nov. 14 from the earliest 'Initial Status' record for the docket and authority type, not from Register publication, which the history file logs only since Sept. 25. The Aug. 23 figures are those CCJ published Aug. 31, on the same definitions; ages at both dates are for stalled files, and across all pending applications the Nov. 14 median is 67 days. The group I followed is every docket, USDOT number and authority type first opened from May 19, when Motus opened to all registrants, through Aug. 16.

The filing field covers liability insurance only: the table's bond field shows a bond or trust on file for 95 of the 1,881 stalled broker and freight forwarder records, 24 of them among the 9,175. I kept them so both dates share a definition. Sixty-eight stalled records have no opening date and are left out of ages. The history file is revised retroactively and incomplete, with only part of the pre-Motus record: the registration table lists 69 of the 9,510 as active and 15 as inactive. I checked every Motus Register issue from May 19 through Nov. 13.

Looking for your next job?
Careersingear.com is the go-to platform for the Trucking industry. Don’t just find the job you need; find the job you want with the company that wants you!